Va'etchanan 5773 – Gilayon #808
(link to original page)
Click here to
receive the weekly parsha by email each week.
Parshat Vaetchanan
You shall do no task, you, and your son, and your
daughter,
And your male slave, and your slavegirl, and your ox, and
your donkey,
And all your beasts and your sojourner who is within
your gates –
So that your male slave and your slavegirl may rest like
you.
And you shall remember that your were a slave in the
And the lord brought you out from there.
(Devarim 5:13-14)
…It says
here "So that your servant and your maid may rest like you, and you shall
remember that you were a slave etc." …He commands rest for the servant
as for yourself because you were a servant and the Lord let you rest, and you
shall let your servant rest, the reason being that when your servant and maid
rest as yourself, you will be reminded that you were a slave, etc".
(Ramban ibid.,
ibid.)
Those
entering the land will no longer be a national conglomeration under the direct
supervision of God; they are to be individuals on their own, and in their work
they will have to struggle with nature and with human competition in order to
merit independence. Therefore the Shabbat was to be impressed above all in its shmira
[‘guarding" i.e., observing the negative precepts] aspect, in its 24- hoursacrifice of ceasing work in acknowledging homage to God. So that those who
henceforth would feel relegated to their own hand and own arm, their own "strength
and power", should not forget the truth that every ounce of strength and
every grain of power, and all that they might come to think was their own
production, comes from God and belongs to God; the God Who showed them His
strength and His power in the midst of the "might and power" of the
great Egyptian state on the slaves who had been "bereft of all strength
and power", and it is He Who has given them the strength and power they
now enjoy and call their own, and Who expects them to acknowledge this fact
with the 24-hour Sabbath sacrifice of refraining from work and carrying [from
one domain to another] … and on the other hand, all the members of this
sphere of man's power are joined to him by the copulative ‘and' in complete
equality with his own personality to place themselves with him at the feet of
God. That is why here "so that your male slave and your slave girl may
rest like you" is stressed as a special visible consequence of the
God-acknowledging festival of Shabbat when Man calls a halt to the exercise of "strength
and powers".
(RaShaR Hirsch, ibid., ibid., Y. Levi translation)
Raised Us Above All Languages?
Debbie Weissman
I would like to dedicate this to the blessed memory of my teacher and
mentor, Prof. Michael Rosenak, who died on Erev Shavuot. Because of Mike
– as he was called by all those who knew him – and his wife, Geula, may she
live a long and good life, I became an observant Jew. When I was
Course. Mike taught us Jewish history and Jewish philosophy. He brought me into
the wonderful world of modern Jewish thought. Mike thus was my teacher, later
my colleague, and, in the end, my friend. The two of us, in the
movement.
One of the central issues in the field of modern Jewish thought is the
concept of Jewish chosenness. Within the framework of these few pages, of
course, it is impossible to deal with the topic in a comprehensive way. I will
simply make one general comment and then a few personal ones: in the modern
era, one of the challenges facing Jewish thinkers , and especially those who
were influenced by the European Enlightenment, is the challenge of racism; in
other words, the belief that some peoples are superior to others. Many
philosophers in the modern period have confronted this challenge and tried to
interpret chosenness in different ways.
In our Parsha, Va'etchanan, we find the following (Deut.
4: 5-
5 See, I have
taught you decrees and laws as the LORD my God
commanded me, so that you may follow them in the land you are
entering to take possession of it. 6 Observe them carefully,
for this will show your wisdom and understanding to the nations,
who will hear about all these decrees and say, "Surely this great nation
is a wise and understanding people." 7
What other nation is so great as to have their gods near them the way the LORD our God is near us whenever we pray to him? 8 And what other nation is so great as to have such
righteous decrees and laws as this body of laws I am setting
before you today? 9 Only be careful,
and watch yourselves closely so that you do not forget the things your eyes
have seen or let them slip from your heart as long as you live. Teach them to your children and to their children after
them. 10 Remember the day you stood before the
LORD your God at Horeb, when he said to me, "Assemble the
people before me to hear my words so that they may learn to
revere me as long as they live in the land and
may teach them to their children."
I want to argue that Jewish chosenness isn't – God forbid! – because of
some kind of essential superiority. It means that we received the Torah
and that our destiny is to share it with the nations of the world. In this, I
am following Rabbi Dr. Immanuel Jacobowitz, former Chief Rabbi of
"Maybe the Greeks were chosen for their unique contributions to
art and philosophy, the Romans for their pioneering services in law and
government, the British for bringing parliamentary rule into the world, and the
Americans for piloting democracy in a pluralistic society."
Rabbi Jacobowitz writes that the Jewish people were chosen by God to be
His peculiar people. He interprets that as "pioneers of religion and
morality." For me, this is going too far; I would have said, "chosen
in order to receive the Torah."
In our blessings and prayers, we connect being chosen with the Torah.
For example, every morning we bless, "Who chose us from among all the
nations and gave us the Torah." In my view, one of the central
contents of Torah – including of the Ten Commandments – is the Shabbat.
In the Friday night Kiddush, we say: "For You have chosen us
from among all peoples and hallowed us above all nations, and in love and favor
have given us Your holy Shabbat…" Thus it is possible to say that
the Election of Israel, or Jewish chosenness, does not necessarily reflect any
superior traits of the people itself, but rather those gifts we received from
the Holy One – the Torah, and, within it, the Shabbat. As long as
we're talking about this kind of Election, without ascribing any qualities of
superiority to any particular people, it is easier to dismiss the danger of
racism.
But I still have difficulty with the expressions ascribing superiority
to our language. In the evening Kiddush for festivals, we say, "You
have raised us above all languages…" and in the festival Mussaf,
we say, "You have exalted us above all tongues."
Is Hebrew
really superior to the thousands of other languages in the world?
Exactly a century ago there took place, in the history of the Yishuv,
what is called the conflict or war of the languages. In
today the Technion – rebelled against their professors, over the issue of the
language of instruction in that institution. Some of the professors preferred
to teach in German; the students insisted on Ivrit. Very quickly the struggle
spread to the whole organized Jewish community in Eretz Yisrael. As you
know, the Hebrew Language was victorious. We can see in the revival of Hebrew
as an everyday spoken language one of the important achievements of the Zionist
movement.2
In Kehillat Yedidya, in Jerusalem, the community to which I
belong (as do many of the writers for "Shabbat Shalom"), we
held this year an all-night study session, a Tikkun Leyl Shavuot, around
the theme, "Hebrew as the Language of Revelation." It is a
fascinating and complex topic. In our study, we saw a text from the Admor
– the Hassidic master – Naftali of Ropschitz (
about the moment of revelation at Sinai: "It could be that the only thing
that was actually heard was the first letter of the first commandment, the Aleph
of Anochi." Aleph is a silent letter. For mystics,
revelation occurred through silence, or, perhaps, "the still, small voice."3
But I am not a mystic. What I have is language, words, and word-play.
The Torah is in Hebrew. And if we start with B'reshit, there's
nothing quite like Hebrew that distinguishes between bara, the word for "created"
when it's God's doing, and yatzar, when it's ours. There is a connection
between yatzar and yetzer, drive or inclination, amen, "so
be it,"
artist, emet, truth, and emunah, faith, hametz, unleavened
bread, and hahmatzat sha'ah, losing the opportunity. Adam, dam
and adamah – man, blood and the earth. Binah, wisdom, is
the ability to distinguish bain l'vain, between different things. The
Midrash doesn't read "Who is like unto You among the mighty, O Lord…"
Mi kamocha ba'elim Hashem," but rather "Mi kamocha ba'eelmim…",4 Who is like unto You, among
the silent…" for the works of Your hands are suffering on earth, and You
remain silent in the heavens.
We say "And you shall teach them diligently unto your children and
speak of them."5
The word for "them" is bam. It is made up of two letters, Bet
and Mem. The Bet is the first letter of the Written Torah,
B'reshit bara…"In the beginning, God created…"The Mem is
the first letter of the Oral Torah, Me’ematai korim…"From when do
we recite?" (At the beginning of the Mishnah in B'rachot.)
Both words – "in the beginning" and "from when?" – are
connected with time, because the Torah helps us to spend wisely the
limited time we have in our lives as mortals. If we take the word for truth, emet,
we see that it's composed of three letters, one from the beginning of the
Hebrew alphabet, one from the middle, and one from the end, because truth
involves a comprehensive perspective on reality. There is a common proverb, "A
lie has no legs to stand on." The three letters of the word for lie, sheker,
are crowded together at the end of the alphabet.
And a word about Purim, which is connected to Shavuot, the festival of
revelation, both through the issue of "the Jews confirmed and took upon
themselves…"6
and through the fact that on both occasions, we read a Scroll named for a woman
(Esther and Ruth.) If we're dealing with Purim, on Purim we dress in costume,
called in Hebrew, mithapsim. The verb to wear a costume is l'hithapes,
in the reflexive form of hitpa'el; in other words, "to search for
yourself:" who you are, who you are not, who you would like to be, who you
really are deep down, and so on. And perhaps l'hapes, to search, is
related to its anagram, lahsof, to reveal?
And finally: the prophet Isaiah (54:
says "And all your children shall be learned of the Lord, and great shall
be the peace of your children." A well-known Midrash continues, "Don't
read this as banayich, your children, but as bonayich, your
builders." In 2009, at the Israel Prize ceremony, Professor Mordecai
Rotenberg, speaking on behalf of the laureates, said that children inherit the
past. Their task is to receive the tradition from their parents. But builders
take the tradition and build on it, shaping it for the future. With regard
to the Torah, the Jewish tradition and Hebrew culture – we are both
heirs and builders.
We could of course keep going and give many more examples. The bottom
line is that there is a deep connection between the Hebrew language, as it has
developed, and the Torah revelation. Perhaps other languages have a
similar potential, I don't know. To the best of my knowledge, other religions,
even when they have sacred scriptures, haven't developed a kind of Midrashic
tradition that de-constructs the holy text, in order to disclose different
possible readings. In Hebrew, this method developed of realizing a wide range
of hermeneutical and homiletical possibilities that are potentially to be found
within the text of the Torah. Thus Hebrew isn't superior to the other
languages; it's different, and the difference is evident in the Midrashic
method. And in this, I believe, lies the uniqueness of Hebrew and of the Jewish
people.
1. The Condition of Jewish Belief, Jason Aronson, Inc.,
2. I am aware that there were Hebrew
speakers and supporters even before this. One of them was the Haredi
thinker Akiva Yosef Schlesinger.
3. See: First Kings
4. This is a pun on Exodus
5. Deuteronomy 6:7
6. Compare Esther 9:27 with Babylonian Talmud
Shabbat 88a.
Debbie Weissman, a founder of Kehillat Yedidya in
serves as president of the
International Council of Christians and Jews
And I
pleaded with the Lord at that time, saying. (Devarim 3:23)
"The
gates of mercy are not locked"
When Moshe
entered the inheritance of the Children of Reuven and the Children of Gad, he
rejoiced and said: I am under the impression that I have been released from my
vow – he began to pour supplications before the King. To what may this be
compared? To a king of flesh and blood who decreed that his son never enter the
door of his hall. When the king entered the gate, the son followed, and [when
he entered] the reception room he followed, but when he came to the
bed-chamber, he said: My son, from here on you may not enter. Similarly, when
Moshe entered the inheritance of the Sons of Reuben and the Sons of Gad, he
rejoiced, saying: It seems that my vow has been cancelled, he began to pour
supplications before the Omnipresent. Is it not a logical conclusion: If Moshe,
who was a great sage, father of the sages and father of the prophets, even
though he know that he was bound by divine decree, still he did not refrain
from pleading for mercy, all the more so other people, as is written: "And
I pleaded to the Lord" (Devarim 3) – with
kinds of supplication.
(Sifri Balak, Piska
"Be
not as servants who serve the master in order to receive reward"
You shall
not try the lord your god as you tried him in massah.
(Devarim 6:
You
shall not try the Lord your God – this is explained by the
phrase as you tried Him in Massah. That is, do not say
"If the Lord is in our midst to perform miracles for us, or if when we
serve Him we succeed, have enough food to satisfy us and live well – then we
shall observe His Torah," for the point of that
[the Massah episode] was that if the Lord would miraculously supplythem with water, then they would follow Him through the wilderness, but if not
they would leave Him. This was accounted to them as a great sin, for after it
had been demonstrated to them with signs and wonders that Moses was a prophet
of the Lord and the Lord's word was truly in his mouth, it was wrong for them
to make any further trial. Anyone who would do so would not be testing the
prophet – he would be testing the blessed Lord to see if His powers were
sufficient to the task. Therefore, it has been prohibited for all the
generations to test the Torah or the Prophets, for it is wrong to serve the
Lord in a doubting fashion, or based upon demands for miracles and tests. It is
not the Lord's will to perform miracles for all persons and at all times, and
it is wrong to serve Him in order to receive a reward. Rather, one may come
across sorrow and tragedy while serving Him and while walking in the
paths of Torah; one should accept that as just, and not be like the fools of
our nation who said [What have we gained by keeping His charge] and
walking in abject awe of the Lord of Hosts? (Malachi 3:
(RaMBaN Devarim 6:
Then moshe
set apart three towns across the
To flee
there who murdered his fellow man without knowing
And he was
not his enemy in time past,
That he
might flee to one of those towns and live.
(Devarim 4:4
Even
one accused of murder is entitled to a decent attitude and a just trial
"Then
Moshe set apart three towns… towards the rising of the sun" – what
is the meaning of "the rising of the sun?"
Said R'
Yossi, son of R' Chanina – said The Holy One, Blessed Be He, to Moshe: Cause
the sun to shine for the murderer and provide him with refuge for exile, so
that he not be doomed because of the sin of murder, just as the sun lights up
the world.
An alternate
explication: "For fleeing to by the accidental murderer" – Our
Rabbis said: To what may this be compared? To an artisan who made an image of
the king; as he was making it, it broke in his hands. Said the king: Had he
broken it intentionally, he would have to be executed; now that he broke it
unintentionally, he is sentenced to exile and travel, so did The Holy One,
Blessed Be He, decree, "Whoever now sheds human blood, for that human
shall his blood be shed", but one who kills without intent is exiled
from his home, as is written, "He shall flee to one of these cities and will
live" – said The Holy One, Blessed Be He: In this world, where
the Evil Inclination is prevalent, people kill each other and they die, but in
the future to come, I will uproot the Evil Inclination from you and there
will be no death in the world, (Isaiah 25), "He
will destroy death forever."
(Devarim Rabba Parasha 2)
"Comfort,
comfort you my people";
A
Conditional Promise or A Spiritual Challenge?
…The
chapter of the Haftara (of Shabbat Nachamu) is cut off at verse 26, and the
four concluding verses are not recited, lest they – Heaven forbid – adversely
affect the pleasant feeling radiated by the preceding verses of consolation
and mission, verses coveted by the human soul, ideas with which the soul
amuses itself.
From the
words of the prophets we derive that consolation and the mission of redemption are
not a given reality or an event due to occur in the future. They are talking
about a direction and a goal towards which one must strive, and this is, in
effect, the meaning of all prophecies which contain promises.
Careful
study, without prejudgments regarding the redemption and the return to Zion,
which are actually the content and the main subjects of the "Seven
Prophecies of Comfort," will reveal – to our surprise- their true meaning:
they are always interwoven with presentations of demands; were this not so,
they would be devoid of any religious significance, and it would have been able
to relate to them as pronouncements of the Oracle, fortune tellers, and
diviners of idolaters, which existed from days of yore until this very day.
In contrast
to one Chazalic opinion which claims that there are only prophecies of
misfortune and that they do not materialize because of penitence which is
capable of nullifying the decree, there is no denying the fact (which we tend
to ignore) that there are to be found many prophecies of consolation which were
never realized. On this subject, too, Talmudic literature, midrashim, and
aggadot make forceful statements, such as those great consolations which
Yirmiyahu predicts for Efrayim and the ten tribes, and for our mother Rachel
who announces the future return of her sons. But we all know that the sons did
not return, and the
of
from the world, despite all these prophecies.
Similarly,
Amos prophesied that Israel will be exiled from its land, and in that same
generation there arose in Israel Yoravam son of Yoash, the powerful leader and
conqueror ' "who restored the territory of Israel from Levo-hamaath to the
sea of the Arabah" (II Kings 14:25), and
achieved victories and conquests hitherto unparalleled, but one generation
later, the Kingdom of Efrayim ceased to exist.
(Y. Leibowitz, Discussions About The Festivals
Of Israel And Its Appointed Times, pp.146-147)
Oz
veShalom needs your support in
order that the voice of a religious Zionism committed to peace and justice will
continue to be heard through the uninterrupted distribution of Shabbat Shalom
in hundreds of synagogues, on the Internet and via email in both Hebrew and
English.
Donations
in
are tax-deductible. Please send your checks made out to "Oz VeShalom"
to Oz VeShalom c/o
Dostrovsky 9/4
9
For a
deductible donation, the New Israel Fund may be used as the conduit.
Contributions should be marked as donor-advised to Oz ve'Shalom, the Shabbat
Shalom project with mention of the registration number 5708.
If you
wish to subscribe to the email English editions of Shabbat Shalom, to print
copies of it for distribution in your synagogue, to inquire regarding the
dedication of an edition in someone's honor or memory, to find out how to make
tax-exempt donations, or to suggest additional helpful ideas, please call
Issues may
be dedicated in honor of an event, person, simcha, etc. Requests must be made
3-4 weeks in advance to appear in the Hebrew,
days in advance to appear in the English email.
About us
Oz Veshalom-Netivot Shalom is a movement dedicated to the
advancement of a civil society in
promoting the ideals of tolerance, pluralism, and justice, concepts that have
always been central to Jewish tradition and law.
Oz Veshalom-Netivot Shalom shares a deep attachment to
the
central religious value. It believes that Jews have both the religious and the
national obligation to support the pursuit of peace. It maintains that Jewish
law clearly requires us to create a fair and just society, and that
co-existence between Jews and Arabs is not an option but an imperative.
4,500 copies of a 4-page peace oriented commentary on the
weekly Torah reading are written and published by Oz VeShalom/Netivot Shalom
and they are distributed to over 350 synagogues in
email
Shabbat Shalom is available on our website: www.netivot-shalom.org.il
For responses and arranging to write for Shabbat
Shalom: pleiser@netvision.net.il